ATTENTION: May 21, 2023 - Main ECNA Forum Boards are now open to MEMBERS ONLY until further notice!

Post reply

Warning: this topic has not been posted in for at least 60 days.
Unless you're sure you want to reply, please consider starting a new topic.
Message icon:


shortcuts: hit alt+s to submit/post or alt+p to preview

Topic Summary

Posted by: Doug K
« on: January 14, 2020, 03:01:59 pm »

Another battle brewing along the Erie Canal in Perinton... thanks to the Facebook Stop Group

Yep... really doesn't matter that the Town of Perinton Planning Board is trying to encourage growth & development in their area. This rezoning and apartment building plan is well documented on the Perinton Town Website, just take a look at the work already done.

Or that the proposal has worked to stay in character with other Canalside Development as seen by the building facade proposal

In the end it's NO different than what was done by Riedman Companies in Fairport...which ALSO met the same type of opposition when they developed The Residences at Canalside. That sold out quickly and put quite bit of money into the local economy I'm sure.

That building lot became an award winning Condo design plan that still had to fight it's way into a municipality that simply refuses to accepts that times are a changing -

Local residents fought against similar Canal Revitalization efforts when that last Condo/Apt buildings were added to Fairport... here's that story.

It appears that the Facebook Stop the Canal Clear Cut group really is more like "Stifle these Community Canal Changes".
Posted by: Doug K
« on: January 14, 2020, 08:01:30 am »

Just have to ask yourself a couple questions when looking at Earthen Embankments...

Is the water at the top of the Embankment, inside the waterway, higher than the topography below the embankment, on the outside where people live

Are there trees on the embankments that could uproot and cause a breach that would cause water to overtop the embankment.

That combination is what will cause flooding, and the one that people seem to ignore the most. I saw pictures around this area that show water above the surrounding ground level, being held back by an earthen bank, with trees that are 6x taller than the berm they are growing out of. Could be the view from Google Earth but in any case unsafe OVERHANGING trees are just as much of a problem as Unsafe Dams.

The NY Canal Corporation is fighting Embankment Safety Issues along with "potential" hazardous conditions a Canal Worker might have while INSPECTING that embankment... Isn't the Canal Corp also worried just as much about overhanging limbs & dying trees falling on the Empire Trail causing injury or death?

I'm sure that has now become one of the talking points in their Embankment Integrity Safety Program... as you will see in their new Embankment Integrity Guidebook when they discuss their need for a "vegetation-free" workzone
Posted by: Michael Caswell
« on: January 13, 2020, 01:40:44 pm »

That's stretching it a bit Doug. The retaining wall on the canal, the foot path, and the highway would have to fail, and its only about 3ft above the waterline. We'd probably need an earthquake for that to happen.

The real embankment ends just before the rowing club building, just south of 31F.
Posted by: Doug K
« on: January 13, 2020, 10:17:08 am »

Never mind... Google has a great view of O'Connor Rd.. right near a dam by a parking lot that is covered by trees. These are the areas that are of concern...the trees are 8 times taller than the earthen embankment they are growing on.. a major issue for issues from uprooting and overhead limbs... these will all have to be removed to conform to the Vegetation-Free zone required for earthen water impounding structures eventually.

Posted by: Doug K
« on: January 13, 2020, 10:05:46 am »

Great News... and they have a small window to work in with their acronym...STCCC

Facebook Stop the Canal Clear Cut or the STCCC as we have called it on our website. Looks like they can morph into Stop the Canal Condo Construction quite easily.

Mike, is the Empire Trail on a raised embankment in this section of the Canal.

I'm not from the area but would imagine a 4 story condo building sitting at the base of a 5 story Earthen Embankment Dam would be an issue on a couple fronts... privacy of those with windows overlooking the Canal Trail.. and building stability being placed on over-saturated ground.

But then again.. It could become the Leaning Tower of Perinton
Posted by: Michael Caswell
« on: January 13, 2020, 09:43:15 am »

I guess they are beginning to see that their Tree crusade is coming to an end, so it appears they are looking for new pastures. What to do next? All that fame and glory, we're a FORCE! We must continue, we're SO important now.

I guess building condos along the canal shoreline could be blended into their 'operation'?